Severance and Collective Bargaining Negotiations

J. Freddy Perera, Esq. is particularly passionate about the psychology of negotiations.

Reviewed by J. Freddy Perera, Esq., Founding Partner · Last updated November 2026

He has published articles and lectured on the psychology of persuasion in labor negotiations.  Freddy has served as the lead negotiator in multi-million-dollar labor negations and regularly handles severance negotiations on behalf of employees and employers.

Severance Negotiations

It is a relatively common practice for employers and employees to seek to formally end their relationship through a severance/separation agreement.  These agreements, when appropriate, allow the parties to amicably part ways without incurring the financial, psychological, and emotional costs of litigation.  Under these agreements, employees are typically provided some level of compensation to reward the employee for past service, aid the employee in the transition, and/or induce the employee to release legal claims he/she may otherwise assert against the employer.

Parties should be cautious when drafting and negotiating severance/separation agreements. In the labor and employment context, there are specific items that are legally prohibited from being in a release agreement or otherwise non-binding without the necessary language.  On the flip side, there is specific language that must be included to release certain employment claims, such as a claim under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act.

Collective Bargaining Negotiations

The labor/management relationship in a collective bargaining setting is one where divorce is virtually impossible.  The parties must work with each other. The relationship is perpetual.  Differences and disagreements do not sever the relationship.  As a result, the parties must be far sighted and cooperative.  It is through this lens that Freddy has handled collective bargaining negotiations in both the public and private sectors.

Below are answers to common questions about severance agreements and collective bargaining in Florida. They are general information, not legal advice about your specific situation.

Is my employer required to pay severance in Florida?

No. Neither Florida nor federal law requires severance pay. An employer owes severance only if it promised it, typically in an employment agreement, offer letter, written severance plan or collective bargaining agreement. Some severance plans are governed by ERISA, the federal benefits law, which has its own claim procedures and deadlines.

Employers with 100 or more employees that carry out a plant closing or mass layoff without giving 60 days’ written notice may owe up to 60 days of pay and benefits under the federal WARN Act. Florida does not have a separate state WARN law.

How long do I have to review a severance agreement?

If you are 40 or older and the agreement releases age discrimination claims, federal law gives you at least 21 days to consider it (45 days if you were let go as part of a group layoff or exit incentive program) and 7 days after signing to change your mind. The agreement must be written in plain language, specifically refer to the Age Discrimination in Employment Act, and advise you in writing to consult a lawyer. In a group layoff, the employer must also give you the job titles and ages of the employees who were selected and not selected.

If you are under 40, no law sets a minimum review period, but you can ask for more time. A reasonable employer rarely says no.

Can I negotiate my severance package?

Often, yes. The first offer is frequently not the final one, especially when the employee has potential claims, has valuable knowledge, or is being asked to accept new restrictions. Terms we commonly negotiate include:

  • The amount, and whether it is paid in a lump sum or over time.
  • Health insurance, such as employer-paid COBRA premiums for a set number of months.
  • Bonuses, commissions and equity that are earned or partly vested.
  • Non-compete and non-solicitation terms, including narrowing or removing them.
  • A neutral reference and an agreed explanation for the departure.
  • Mutual non-disparagement, so the obligation runs both ways.
  • An agreement not to contest unemployment benefits.

Leverage depends on the facts. An employee with a credible discrimination, retaliation, whistleblower or unpaid wage claim is in a very different position from one without a claim. That is why it pays to have the situation reviewed before you respond.

What rights can’t be waived in a severance agreement?

Some rights cannot be signed away, and an agreement that tries to waive them may be partly unenforceable. For example:

  • You cannot give up the right to file a charge with, or take part in an investigation by, the EEOC or a similar agency, although you can usually waive the right to recover money from that charge.
  • In Florida and the rest of the federal Eleventh Circuit, claims for unpaid minimum wage or overtime under the FLSA generally cannot be released privately. A settlement of those claims normally needs court approval or U.S. Department of Labor supervision.
  • A release generally cannot waive claims that arise after it is signed, vested retirement benefits, or rights to unemployment benefits provided by law.

For non-supervisory employees, the National Labor Relations Board has also found that overly broad confidentiality and non-disparagement clauses can violate federal labor law. The Board’s approach has shifted with changes in its membership, so these clauses should be drafted with current law in mind.

Does severance affect unemployment benefits in Florida?

It can. Severance pay may delay or reduce Florida Reemployment Assistance benefits for the weeks it covers, depending on how the payment is structured. Review how and when payments will be made before you sign. An employer’s agreement not to contest your claim helps, but the state still decides whether you are eligible.

Are severance payments taxable?

Yes. Severance is generally treated as wages and is subject to income and payroll tax withholding. Some severance arrangements, especially payments spread over time, must also be structured to comply with federal deferred compensation rules (Section 409A of the Internal Revenue Code). Talk to a tax adviser about your situation.

Do Florida employees have the right to unionize and bargain collectively?

Yes. The Florida Constitution protects the right of employees to bargain collectively. Florida is also a right-to-work state: no one can be required to join a union or pay union dues as a condition of employment. Private-sector bargaining is governed by the federal National Labor Relations Act and the NLRB. Bargaining by state and local government employees is governed by Chapter 447 of the Florida Statutes and overseen by the Public Employees Relations Commission (PERC). Public employees in Florida may not strike.

What changed for Florida public-sector unions in 2023?

A 2023 Florida law (SB 256) changed the rules for most public-sector unions, other than those representing law enforcement officers, correctional officers and firefighters. Among other things, those unions:

  • can no longer have dues deducted from employees’ paychecks;
  • must report each year whether at least 60% of the employees in the bargaining unit are dues-paying members; and
  • must petition PERC for recertification if membership falls below that level.

For public employers and unions alike, these rules affect how bargaining is planned and how unit membership is tracked.

What happens when public-sector negotiations reach impasse in Florida?

Under Florida law, either side may declare impasse. Unless the parties agree to skip it, the dispute then goes to a special magistrate, who holds a hearing and issues recommendations. If either side rejects the recommendations, the legislative body (such as the city commission, county commission or school board) holds a public hearing and decides the disputed issues. Because the legislative body has the final word, careful preparation at every stage matters, from the first proposal to the final hearing.

Call to Schedule an Appointment

Se Habla Español: (786) 485-5232

info@pba-law.com
·  Mon – Fri: 9:00AM – 5:00PM